Friday, September 24, 2010

HENRYs = High Earners Not Rich Yet?

That's what the Harvard Business Review (HBR) and Fortune Magazine are calling it. HBR editor Justin Fox writes:

The Tax Plight of the $250,000 to $500,000 Crowd

My former colleague at Fortune magazine, Shawn Tully, has been trying for a while to popularize an acronym of his devising: HENRYs, for high earners, not rich yet. Yes, it's a stretch, but it describes a real phenomenon: Very successful households (two-income couples, mostly), on the young side, who are making $250,000-$500,000 a year but don't have a whole lot in the way of assets — and may have big housing and/or education debts — don't feel particularly rich, and bear just about the heaviest tax burden of any income group....

...They're well-represented among HBR.org readers, and they're the fulcrum of the current U.S. tax debate. The tax cuts pushed by the Bush administration and approved by Congress at the beginning of this decade are set to expire next year (because the Bush administration and Congress were unwilling to come up with any spending cuts to make up for the revenue loss). The Obama administration wants to preserve most of the cuts, but only for those making less than $250,000 a year. So $250,000 marks the dividing line between the middle class, who are deemed deserving of continued tax relief, and the rich, who are not.

It's not the craziest of dividing lines: Only about 2% of American households take in more than $250,000 a year, so while there are many words that can be used to describe this income group, "middle" clearly is not one of them. It's also not as sharp a line as it's often made out to be: the higher tax rates would apply to income over $250,000 (or so), not every penny that the HENRYs make.


Actually, the Harvard Business Review doesn't have that quite right. And they are not alone in their misconception.

The Obama administration does NOT proposing to tax income over $250,000 at higher rates, it is proposing to tax "taxable income" over $250,000" at higher rates.

For a typical HENRY couple, there is a big difference between their "income" and their "taxable income."

Start with their gross wages and investment income. That's what most people think of when you refer to their "income."

But that is not what the Obama tax proposal targets at all when it sets that $250,000 figure for raising marginal rates.

Let's take an example HENRY family to illustrate. Let's say they are a married 2-earner couple with two kids who live in New York State in the suburbs of New York City.

They made $350,000 in wages last year. (We'll leave aside their investment income for the moment, assuming their investments are all in a 401(k) plan or an IRA or perhaps their investment income is in the form of unrealized capital gains, so it doesn't even show up on their current tax return.)

Will they get hit with the higher tax rates that the Obama administration folks?

Quite possibly not! Why? Because their taxable income is very likely under $250,000.

Start with the $350,000. They can each put in up to $16,500 into their 401(k) plans, which means that $33,000 gets excluded from their income for tax purposes right off the top. Now we are down to $317,000.

Also, they can each put $5,000 into flexible spending accounts to pay for childcare (a nanny, a baby sitter, daycare centers, even daycamp in the summer.) They also put $2,500 each into their health care flex spending accounts. Knock off another $15,000 from income for tax purposes. Now we are down to $302,000 in what the IRS refers to as "Total Income" (Line 22 of Form 1040).

But, wait, there's more! (As they say on late night TV infomercials.)

They get to subtract itemized deductions and personal and dependency exemptions. A reasonable estimate of property taxes paid on a home in suburban New York is $15,000. Their mortgage interest might run around $35,000. They also pay about $20,000 in New York State income tax. Even if they give little or nothing to charity, their itemized deductions and exemptions will knock their taxable income below $250,000. (Exactly how far below $250,000 is a slightly complicated calculation, due to phaseouts and other bed buffaloes in the tax code.)

So we started with a family with an "income" of $350,000, as most people define the term income, and wound up with a taxable income below $250,000, safely out of range of the administration's proposed increase in tax rates.

And wait, there's even more for the true policy wonks like your professor! The Haig-Simons definition of their true economic income would likely be well over $350,000, because you'd have to add in employer contributions to health care, employer matching contributions to retirement plans, other tax-free fringe benefits provided by the employer (life insurance, disability insurance, tuition assistance, incentive stock options, commuting benefits such as free transit passes or a bicycle or vanpool or free parking, an employer-provided on-promises family gym membership.) The broadest Haig-Simons definition of income would also include the value of unrealized capital gains on their investments, as well as imputed value of other services they consume (e.g., owner-occupied housing, cars, consumer durables) and other items.

But, even leaving Haig-Simons aside, it is clear that households can have gross incomes well above $250,000 and still remain untouched by the administration proposal to raise marginal tax rates on taxable incomes over $250,000.

57 comments:

  1. A family that has this much in deductions (esp. state income and property taxes and child related deductions) at an income this high is pretty likely to be getting hit by the AMT.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your calculations are overstated, both earners cannot deduct 5k "each" for FSA. Also, if both are putting 2.5k each into HSA then they need to use those 5k for medical outlays only. Unless one of them (or one of their children) is extremely sick (remember that they already have insurance from their jobs). There is no way that they will be spending 5k a year in medical expenses. So, it is very unlikely that each is putting 2.5k into an HSA (more like 1k each and less makes a lot more sense).
    Finally, you forgot AMT!!! if someone has income of 350k but taxable income of less than 250k then AMT will come in and bit that family in the rear. It is clear that your analysis is very biased!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh, and I forgot one more thing... not every High Earner lives in NY or NJ, so 35k in mortgage expense and 20k in state taxes does not resonate across the country!

    ReplyDelete
  4. AMT, AMT, AMT! They may never have benefited from the Bush tax cuts, as they have been paying the higher AMT rate for years! But it is true that HENRY's get slammed, especially in high cost of living areas like New York. People in other part's of the country have no perspective or sense for what it costs to live in the Tri-State area. HENRY's are not Bill Gates wealthy. They are not "millionaires and billionaires" as Obama would have it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. NBA Basketball Jerseys Online
    If you are searching for a family owned and operated Basketball Jerseys Factory to buy Cheap NBA Jerseys Authentic, Klay Thompson Jerseys and NBA Basketball Jerseys Online, then your search ends at NBA Jerseys Factory.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It is perfect time to make a few plans for the long run and it is time to be happy. I have read this post and if I may I wish to suggest you few attention-grabbing things or suggestions. Perhaps you can write subsequent articles relating to this article. I want to read even more things about it!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Congratulations on your article, it was very helpful and successful. 3fe315ff205fd155e83152465350f07a
    website kurma
    website kurma
    sms onay

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you for your explanation, very good content. e24ee1d0dc5d401bb4a445902a6cad11
    define dedektörü

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you for your explanation, very good content. 5cacaabe4deee96d00fcbc883e49dff1
    evden iş imkanı

    ReplyDelete
  10. You may purchase likes, comments, and views on social media using an SMM panel service. An Cheap Smm Panel might help you get more views and likes on your YouTube videos. By doing this, you may draw more viewers to your videos and increase their visibility in YouTube's search results.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Increase your internet visibility without breaking the budget by utilizing our most cheapest SMM panel on the market."

    ReplyDelete
  12. The SMM Panel is a centralized platform that allows you to schedule posts, analyze performance analytics, and engage with followers.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Practitioners may also incorporate different massage techniques, kneading, and gentle manipulation to enhance relaxation and effectiveness

    ReplyDelete
  14. In Bali, massage is not just a physical practice; it is often considered a spiritual and healing ritual.

    ReplyDelete
  15. An online platform that is centrally located and dedicated to Social Media Marketing SMM Panel. In order to effectively disseminate content, engage audiences, and make data-driven decisions, it is especially helpful for those to maintain a strong online presence across multiple social media platforms.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Explore the world of soothing female to male body massage at home treatments to couples' sessions, discover the perfect massage center for you.

    ReplyDelete
  17. It’s a great way to spice things up in the bedroom and get to know your partner’s preferences and what makes them turned on.

    ReplyDelete

  18. Utilizing electromagnetic induction heater technology brings significant advantages in terms of efficiency, safety, and eco-friendliness. Unlike traditional heating methods, these systems eliminate the requirement for intermediary heat transfer substances, ensuring swift and efficient heating directly to the intended object. Moreover, their reliance on electromagnetic field heating eradicates open flames and exhaust emissions, effectively reducing potential safety hazards and environmental pollutants.

    ReplyDelete
  19. The FintechZoom Hublot Spirit is a symphony of cutting-edge technical advancements and classic Swiss workmanship. It is more than just a watch. A singular experience is set in motion by the timeless fusion of the past and future, which is echoed by every tick and tock. Visit here:walkerfeed

    ReplyDelete

  20. In drawing the curtains on the exploration of wellhealthorganic.com:jaggery-with-incredible-health-benefits, one is left with a resounding appreciation for the myriad ways this natural sweetener can transform our well-being.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Boost your online presence with our flexible social media panel. Our platform is designed to meet the various requirements of both individuals and businesses, acting as a single point of contact for all of your social media marketing activities.

    ReplyDelete
  22. The techtonica water wheel ratio can also present some challenges initially, but with the right knowledge, you’ll become adept at harnessing its abilities to generate extra energy.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Buy YouTube Subscribers" is a widely-utilized growth strategy among new content creators to bolster their channel's perceived popularity and reach. This method involves procuring subscribers from reputable sources to augment the channel's subscriber count. Although this can provide an initial boost, it's crucial to ensure these subscribers are authentic to prevent any infringement of YouTube's guidelines. Moreover, it's essential to complement this strategy with a robust content plan to encourage viewer engagement and organic growth. Always remember, while buying subscribers can initiate channel growth, the long-term success relies heavily on consistently delivering quality content that resonates with the audience. Hence, this strategy should be approached with caution and a clear understanding of its potential implications and limitations.
    https://www.buyyoutubesubscribers.in/

    ReplyDelete
  24. Delhi's LASIK surgery landscape is an exemplary sector where cutting-edge laser technology is utilised by world-class surgeons for impeccable results. Offering customised procedures at globally competitive prices, these clinics provide excellent value while upholding rigorous international safety standards. Post-operative care is comprehensive, ensuring patients experience a quick and smooth recovery process, and most clients report significant vision improvement shortly after surgery. Delhi's fusion of affordability, expert care, and advanced medical technology makes it an outstanding choice for anyone seeking to correct their vision with confidence and peace of mind.
    https://www.visualaidscentre.com/lasik-eye-surgery/

    ReplyDelete
  25. The purchase of cheap YouTube subscribers is a controversial strategy that aims to artificially inflate a channel's perceived importance. Predicated on the assumption that higher numbers signal greater credibility, this tactic trades instant gratification for genuine community building. Despite momentarily boosting subscriber counts, such an approach does little to improve viewer participation or content quality. It runs the gauntlet of YouTube’s stringent algorithms, which may impose severe penalties on channels with such dishonest growth patterns. Consequently, what is sold as a shortcut to popularity can, in fact, undermine the true essence of content creation – authentic engagement and a loyal viewership.
    https://sites.google.com/view/buyytsubscribers/

    ReplyDelete
  26. "Buy Real YouTube Views" is a specialized service that assists YouTube creators in amplifying the online presence and visibility of their content. It provides a platform where real views by genuine users are made available, offering a legitimate method to boost a video’s reach and search rankings within YouTube. The service operates within the bounds of YouTube's comprehensive policies, ensuring no infringement on the site's strict guidelines. With an emphasis on ethical standards, it seeks to maintain the integrity of the creator's channel while enhancing their potential for organic growth. Particularly beneficial for new content creators, it serves as a foundational step towards constructing a reputable and engaging online presence. It is a strategic tool aimed at elevating user engagement and increasing viewership metrics in a competitive digital environment.
    https://www.buyyoutubeviewsindia.in/

    ReplyDelete
  27. India's landscape of affordable web hosting is dynamic, offering impressive cost-efficiency for those eager to make their mark online. These services provide substantial storage and bandwidth, indispensable for a growing digital presence. Reliability is a given, with strong uptime guarantees and accessible customer support. One-click WordPress installations and user-friendly control panels cater to both novices and tech-savvy users. Complimentary SSL certificates across plans promise a secure browsing experience for website visitors. Additionally, included email hosting services add a layer of professionalism. Such economically priced hosting solutions are reshaping the digital ecosystem, making it inclusive for entrepreneurs and visionaries across demographics.
    https://onohosting.com/

    ReplyDelete
  28. Pursuing the route of 'buy YouTube subscribers cheap' typically entails a deceptive boost in channel subscribers, ostensibly at low cost. These subscribers, often bots or inactive users, do not engage with the content—offering no likes, comments, or shares—thus contributing nothing to the channel's organic growth. Utilizing such a service blatantly violates YouTube's policies, risking severe penalties from reduced visibility to the channel's termination. The illusion of a larger audience fails to deceive savvy viewers and algorithms, as such metrics are shallow and do not reflect a vibrant, interactive community. In essence, cheap subscribers are a hollow investment that may harm a channel's reputation more than aid its growth.
    https://buyyoutubesubscribersindia.weebly.com/

    ReplyDelete
  29. Purchasing 5-star Google reviews can artificially inflate a business's online reputation, presenting an alluring facade of high customer satisfaction and quality service. This controversial practice is seen by some as a quick fix to compensate for inadequate real customer feedback. Companies that engage in buying reviews may find a short-term boost in their online presence, potentially attracting more customers based on these enhanced ratings. However, this tactic undermines the authenticity of the review platform and violates Google's policies, risking penalties and damage to the business's credibility in the long run.
    https://www.seoexpertindelhi.in/buy-google-reviews/

    ReplyDelete
  30. Join our dynamic healthcare team in Singapore and elevate your nursing career! We are seeking dedicated Indian nurses ready to embrace challenges and opportunities in a technologically advanced environment. With a commitment to diversity and professional growth, we offer competitive salaries, ongoing training, and a supportive multicultural workplace. Become an integral part of a city-state renowned for its exceptional patient care and innovative medical practices. Apply now to make a profound impact and gain unparalleled experience in one of Asia's top healthcare systems. Let Singapore be the next milestone in your fulfilling nursing journey.
    https://dynamichealthstaff.com/nursing-jobs-in-singapore-for-indian-nurses

    ReplyDelete
  31. Discover unmatched value with our wallet-friendly web hosting solutions in India, designed for the savvy entrepreneur. Our competitively priced plans ensure you don't compromise on quality, offering steadfast uptime and impressive loading speeds. Effortlessly manage your online space with our straightforward control panel and user-centric app integrations. Encounter no barriers to growth; our scalable resources expand with your venture. Always sleep soundly with 24/7 customer support and rigorous security that fortifies your website against cyber threats, all while securing your budget. Choose us for a hosting service where cost-saving meets peak performance.
    https://hostinglelo.in/

    ReplyDelete
  32. Immerse your business in the transformative power of our "Buy Google Reviews Bulk India" service, a strategic tool designed for Indian companies eager to elevate their digital presence. With a suite of competitively priced, authentic-seeming testimonials, our service seamlessly integrates into your marketing mix, delivering a boost in consumer confidence and search engine visibility. We specialize in generating high-caliber, ethical reviews that replicate the rich diversity of the Indian market, offering you an edge in a competitive digital world. As each review amplifies your brand's reliability, watch as your enterprise stands out, accruing trust and conversion rates that are unmatchable. Opt for our service, and you're not just buying reviews; you're investing in a reputation for excellence.
    https://www.sandeepmehta.co.in/buy-google-reviews/

    ReplyDelete
  33. Elevate your music career by purchasing Spotify streams, a strategic move for increasing your visibility and reach. With each stream, your songs gain momentum, attracting more listeners and boosting your credibility as an artist. Buying Spotify streams is an investment in your success, as it can lead to increased followers and playlist placements. Don't underestimate the power of targeted promotion; buying streams can help you stand out in a crowded market. Take control of your Spotify journey by investing in streams today and watch your music climb the charts. Experience the impact of amplified streams and unlock new opportunities for recognition and growth on Spotify. Don't wait for organic growth; buy Spotify streams and accelerate your path to success in the music industry.
    https://www.spotifyfame.com/

    ReplyDelete
  34. Boost your Twitch presence by purchasing followers for your channel. Buying Twitch followers is a strategic way to increase your channel's credibility and attract more viewers. Each follower you buy contributes to your channel's visibility, making it more likely to attract organic growth. With bought followers, you can jumpstart your Twitch journey and gain momentum quickly. Don't underestimate the power of a strong follower count; it can attract sponsorships and collaborations. Invest in Twitch followers today and witness immediate growth. Experience the benefits of targeted promotion and unlock new opportunities for success on the platform.
    https://twitchviral.com/

    ReplyDelete
  35. Visit our hot male and female massage centers to experience hot massages. Come soon and enjoy hot massages. Our hot-massage ladies are certified and highly trained.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Aromatherapy is the application of essential oils from plants for relaxation and therapeutic effects. Aromatherapy can be used in male to female massages, or even the air. Our therapists have a high level of experience and are certified. You can relax while they care for your skin.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Looking to expand your YouTube reach without breaking the bank? Consider the option to buy YouTube views cheap. With affordable packages, you can instantly boost your video's visibility and attract more viewers. Skip the hefty investments and opt for cost-effective solutions to elevate your content. Increase your video's credibility and gain traction in the competitive YouTube space. Engage a wider audience and unlock opportunities for organic growth. Don't let budget constraints hold you back from reaching your goals. Invest smartly in your content and watch your views soar without draining your wallet. Take control of your YouTube journey today with affordable views that deliver results.
    https://sites.google.com/site/buyytviewindia/

    ReplyDelete
  38. Transform your gaze with Smile Pro Eye Surgery in Delhi, a revolutionary solution for brighter, more youthful eyes. Say goodbye to tired-looking eyes and hello to a refreshed, confident appearance. Our expert surgeons utilize advanced techniques to reduce under-eye bags and wrinkles, ensuring natural-looking results tailored to your needs. Experience the joy of seeing the world through rejuvenated eyes, filled with newfound radiance. With Smile Pro, embrace a future where your eyes reflect your inner vitality and beauty. Trust in our expertise to enhance your natural allure with Smile Pro Eye Surgery in Delhi.
    https://smileproeyesurgery.medium.com/smile-pro-eye-surgery-in-delhi-fbafc721a9ce

    ReplyDelete
  39. Revitalize your eyes with the Smile Pro Eye Procedure in Delhi, a transformative experience redefining eye aesthetics. Our advanced techniques, coupled with expert care, ensure a radiant and youthful gaze. Bid farewell to tired eyes and welcome a brighter, more confident you. Tailored to your needs, this procedure unveils your natural beauty with precision and finesse. Embrace the future of eye rejuvenation and let your eyes radiate with newfound vibrancy. Discover the difference with Smile Pro in the heart of Delhi, where every procedure is a step towards timeless beauty. Book your consultation today and embark on the journey to brighter, more captivating eyes.
    https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/smile-pro-eye-surgery-delhi-romila-chaudhary-y5imc/

    ReplyDelete
  40. Experience the transformative benefits of Silk Eye Surgery, the pinnacle of vision correction technology. Bid farewell to glasses and contacts as we reshape your vision with precision and care. Our skilled surgeons employ state-of-the-art techniques to ensure optimal results tailored to your needs. Rediscover life with clarity and confidence, liberated from the constraints of refractive errors. Silk Eye Surgery offers a safe and effective solution for a spectrum of vision issues, from nearsightedness to astigmatism. Entrust your vision to us and embark on a journey to clearer sight and brighter days. Say hello to a new chapter of visual freedom with Silk Eye Surgery.
    https://medium.com/@pojagupta/silk-eye-surgery-elita-860c70c593ad

    ReplyDelete
  41. Crafting excellence, Award Makers transform dreams into tangible recognition. With precision and artistry, they mold raw materials into symbols of achievement. Each stroke, each detail, a testament to dedication and skill. Behind every award lies a story of perseverance and triumph, immortalized in metal and crystal. From humble beginnings to grand stages, Award Makers illuminate the path to greatness. They breathe life into aspirations, forging connections that inspire generations. Celebrating moments of glory, they etch memories in time, forever cherished. In the hands of Award Makers, dreams become reality, and achievements shine ever brighter.
    https://www.angelstrophies.com/

    ReplyDelete
  42. Seeking legal counsel for your divorce in Dwarka? Look no further! Our experienced divorce lawyers in Dwarka provide expert guidance and support through this challenging time. With a compassionate approach, we strive to achieve fair resolutions for our clients. From mediation to litigation, we offer personalized strategies tailored to your needs. Trust our team to navigate the complexities of divorce proceedings with professionalism and empathy. Contact us today for a consultation and take the first step towards a brighter future.
    https://bestdivorcelawyerindelhi.com/

    ReplyDelete
  43. A Breast Cancer Doctor in Mumbai is recognized for their unparalleled expertise and dedication in the realm of oncology, specifically focusing on breast cancer. With a rich foundation of knowledge and ongoing participation in cutting-edge research, they remain at the forefront of innovative treatment strategies. These professionals are not just skilled in surgical interventions but are also compassionate listeners, understanding the fears and hopes of their patients. Their approach to care is holistic, considering not only the physical implications of breast cancer but also its psychological impact. They prioritize clear communication, ensuring patients are fully informed about their diagnosis, treatment options, and prognosis. In collaboration with a multidisciplinary team, they tailor treatments to each patient's unique situation, aiming for the best possible outcomes. Above all, their commitment to their patients extends beyond the confines of the hospital, advocating for breast cancer awareness and prevention in the broader community.
    https://drnitanair.com/

    ReplyDelete
  44. In Ahmedabad, an Esophageal Cancer Specialist stands as a pillar of expertise and hope in the realm of gastrointestinal cancers. Recognized for their deep understanding of esophageal cancer's complexities, they bring forward a blend of advanced diagnostic capabilities and a comprehensive range of treatment modalities. Their toolbox spans from minimally invasive endoscopic procedures to complex surgical resections, complemented by cutting-edge chemotherapy, radiation, and novel targeted therapies. These specialists prioritize a multidisciplinary approach, ensuring patients receive a tailored and cohesive treatment strategy. With a compassionate touch, they guide their patients through each step, offering not only medical treatment but also psychological support and nutritional advice, integral to coping with esophageal cancer. Their commitment to innovation and patient care is evident in their participation in ongoing research and dedication to educating the community about risk factors and early detection. In essence, Ahmedabad's Esophageal Cancer Specialists embody hope and healing, providing personalized and advanced care to those in their charge.
    https://drvirajlavingia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  45. The Breast Cancer Doctor in Gurgaon is distinguished by their holistic and innovative approach towards combating breast cancer. These professionals are not only adept at employing the latest therapeutic procedures and technologies, but they also place a strong emphasis on compassionate care. Their treatment regimes are deeply personalized, ensuring that each patient's unique health scenario is addressed with the utmost precision. The integration of advanced research and clinical trials into their practice allows for the application of cutting-edge treatments that promise better outcomes. Furthermore, they are deeply involved in preventive care and patient education, empowering individuals to take proactive steps towards their health. Their commitment to emotional support extends the scope of their care beyond the physical aspects of the disease, fostering a nurturing and hopeful environment. Through their efforts, the Breast Cancer Doctor in Gurgaon represents a beacon of excellence and empathy in the ongoing battle against breast cancer.
    https://www.breastoncosurgery.com/

    ReplyDelete
  46. Exciting opportunity alert! Staff Nurse vacancy in the UK without IELTS requirement. Join our dynamic team and embark on a fulfilling career path. Enjoy the chance to work in a diverse healthcare environment without language barriers. We value your skills and experience, offering competitive benefits and career advancement opportunities. Skip the hassle of language exams and apply today to start your journey as a Staff Nurse in the UK. Don't let language hurdles hold you back – seize this opportunity now!
    https://suntechhealthcarepro.com/staff-nurse-vacancy-in-uk-without-ielts/

    ReplyDelete